Make us your home page


Education news and notes from Tampa Bay and Florida

Florida third-grade promotion decisions are local, Department of Education official says

Florida school districts that are requiring third graders to have a test score to avoid repeating the grade have misunderstood state directives, a Department of Education spokeswoman told the Gradebook.

"Our primary guidance to the districts is to follow the law," spokeswoman Meghan Collins said Tuesday. "Obviously, the law says participation on the FSA (Florida Standards Assessment) is mandatory. But we never said you must retain a student who doesn't have an FSA score."

Moreover, Collins continued, the department never said that a student must sit for an alternate test before gaining access to other good cause exemptions for promotion allowed in law and rule.

"There is no hierarchy" of exemptions, she said. Decisions to mandate a secondary test, the SAT-10, come from the districts, she added. "That wouldn't be something we would intervene in."

Some districts, including Manatee and Sarasota, have asserted the state dictated that students must have a test score or be retained. They referred to a department email summarizing state law and rule on the subject.  …

Full Story

Florida Board of Education vice chairman calls for required computer science instruction

After the Florida Board of Education adopted new computer science standards May 20, at least one prominent critic was not impressed: Florida State University physics professor Paul Cottle called the adoption a "meaningless gesture" because it didn't include a plan to recruit needed computer science teachers to the state.

State Board of Education vice chairman John Padget is taking issue with that characterization. A vocal advocate for computer instruction, Padget viewed the decision as a needed first step for a state that's too far behind in the critical curriculum area.

"Computer science must be front and center in Florida's drive to create jobs. Success in all our job-creating enterprises -- tourism, agriculture, engineering, logistics, construction, and the financial industries -- can be linked back to excellence in computer science," Padget wrote in a letter to media. "Such will not be an option for Florida's future; it's a prerequisite."

He called for a three-year computer science plan that includes expansion of the teaching force, added credentials for math and science teachers, and incentives for relevant industry certifications, among other steps. …

Full Story

Pasco superintendent considers procedures for classroom book assignments

Having dealt with a specific challenge to the novel The Perks of Being a Wallflower, Pasco County schools superintendent Kurt Browning wants to turn his attention to the way teachers assign any books that aren't part of the district-adopted curriculum.

His goal: To avoid more situations where parents object to content after seeing it without any sort of warning.

Browning is considering a procedure in which teachers would send home a list of the novels their classes will read during the semester. That list would go out in the first week of classes, along with a brief explanation of the connection to academic standards and an alert to any potentially upsetting content.

"We need to let parents know ahead of time what materials are being used," Browning said. "Then the onus is put upon the parents to review the materials."

If they have concerns, they could ask the teacher for an alternative novel selected by the teacher that still meets the intended lesson. …

Full Story

Florida education news: Retirement, testing, fund raisers and more

NEW DIRECTIONS: Three Bay County kindergarten teachers retire after working a combined 108 years together, the Panama City News Herald reports.

OPPORTUNITIES: A Miami-Dade girl with multiple disabilities overcomes her obstacles to succeed in a traditional classroom, the Miami Herald reports.

TESTING: Term-limited Sen. Don Gaetz is hopeful lawmakers will reconsider his failed bill to allow students and schools alternatives to state tests, Politico Florida reports.

SPECULATION: A Palm Beach County private school sees its headmaster depart at the same time the school hires two law firms to look into whether any students were sexually abused, the Palm Beach Post reports.

EXTRA HELP: A Tallahassee girl who is legally blind raises more than $1 million to help other blind children gain services in and out of school, People reports.

RETENTION: Manatee parents prepare to face off with their school district over third-grade retention decisions, the Bradenton Times reports.

NEW SCHOOLS: The Orange County school district plans $3 billion in new school construction to deal with growth, the Orlando Sentinel reports. …

Full Story

Charter school management company Newpoint Education Partners pleads not guilty

Newpoint Education Partners logo

Screenshot from

Newpoint Education Partners logo

Newpoint Education Partners, a charter school management company that was indicted along with three related companies earlier this month, has pleaded not guilty to charges of grand theft, money laundering and aggravated white collar crime.

Attorneys appeared on the company's behalf in Escambia County court on Thursday, said state prosecutor Russell Edgar, and submitted written pleas. It is unclear whether the attorneys represented just Newpoint or the other related companies as well, which are Epiphany Management Group, Red Ignition and School Warehouse. He said the case has since been taken off of the docket, and prosecutors are still working on a witness list and responding to the attorneys' request for discovery.

A grand jury charged the companies with laundering money and fraudulently billing schools for supplies, equipment and services with federal start-up grant funds for charter schools. Times investigation found that similar activity has occurred in Pinellas County, where Newpoint managed five charter schools. …

Full Story

Florida education news: Crowding, vouchers, retention and more

CROWDING: Thousands of Florida students could pour into crowded public schools if the courts eventually find tax credit scholarships unconstitutional.

SUPERINTENDENTS: Four of five Hernando School Board members give superintendent Lori Romano a solid evaluation.

TOP STUDENTS: Proflies of "Great Grads" from Plant High, Jesuit High and Newsome High.

NEVER TOO LATE: An Opa-Locka woman completes her high school diploma decades after starting, WSVN reports.

HEALTHY SCHOOLS: The Manatee school district considers opening a walk-in health clinic for employees, the Bradenton Herald reports.

THIRD-GRADE RETENTION: The Manatee school district stands by its position that portfolios may be used only for students who have taken and done poorly on tests, despite actions by other districts, the Bradenton Herald reports.

ON POLITICS: Miami-Dade School Board member Raquel Regalado resigns her seat in advance of her expected run for county mayor, the Miami Herald reports.

MOVING ON: The Ocala Star-Banner continues its chronicle of children in the class of 2020 as they prepare to enter high school. …

Full Story

ICYMI: Florida education news, week of May 23, 2016

It's been another busy week in Florida education news. A circuit judge ruled that Florida's education funding model was indeed adequate. Parents in some counties started fighting their districts over third-grade retention decisions. A Pasco school banned a popular young adult novel. State leaders focused on further reducing costs for Florida's university students. And that's just the start. Check out the highlights below, and visit the Gradebook daily for the latest.

Pasco superintendent will not ban challenged novel in all schools, Jeffrey S. Solochek
"A review committee's proposal to remove Stephen Chbosky's novel The Perks of Being a Wallflower from Pasco Middle School will stand, but only for that school, district spokeswoman Linda Cobbe told the Gradebook."
COLUMN: Banning a book is the real obscenity in this case, John Romano …

Full Story

Phil Jones steps down as Hillsborough Education Foundation chief

Phil Jones is retiring as president of the Hillsborough Education Foundation


Phil Jones is retiring as president of the Hillsborough Education Foundation

Barnie Philip “Phil” Jones, who led the Hillsborough Education Foundation for three years after a successful career in retail coffee, has retired, the organization announced Friday.

A search committee will seek a new president while senior marketing director Virginia McGrath serves as interim president. 

Jones founded Barnie's Coffee & Tea Shop Inc. in 1980 and later sold it to the Sara Lee company.

He was hired in 2012 at the education foundation, a nonprofit organization that supports the work of the Hillsborough County School District. As president, he is credited for expanding the organization's college scholarship programs and Teaching Tools, a "store" that provides free classroom supplies for teachers in low-income schools. 

Full Story

Florida education rules permit portfolios for promotion to fourth grade

Much is being made these days of some Florida school districts that are refusing to promote third graders without a state reading test score -- even if the children are achieving above grade level in class.

Parents argue the test score isn't needed, suggesting that only students with demonstrated reading deficiencies should be subject to the requirements. District officials recite state law to counter the claim, saying the testing rules on social promotion apply equally to all students.

Regardless of that disagreement, nowhere in the state law does it say that a child with a poor score, or no score, must take an alternate test to the Florida Standard Assessment before seeking a portfolio option. In fact, the law offers a portfolio as an equal good cause exemption to an alternate assessment:

3. Students who demonstrate an acceptable level of performance on an alternative standardized reading or English Language Arts assessment approved by the State Board of Education.
4. A student who demonstrates through a student portfolio that he or she is performing at least at Level 2 on the statewide, standardized English Language Arts assessment.

Full Story

Florida education news: Turnaround students, geography, home schooling and more

COMEBACK KIDS: Pasco County students find success after overcoming the struggles of family loss, drug use, homelessness and more.

NEXT GENERATION: Pasco's River Ridge High School launches a teaching academy for students interested in the profession.

TOP STUDENTS: Meet Pinellas County's public school valedictorians and salutatorians. • A Williams Middle Magnet School sixth grader wins the national geography bee.

HOME SCHOOLING: The country's largest home-schooling convention will come to Florida, WFTV reports.

THIRD GRADE RETENTION: A Seminole mom says she wants to sue the school district for retaining her third grader who opted out of state testing, WESH reports. More from WKMG, WTSP, Herald-Tribune.

CHARTER SCHOOLS: Duval district officials have no plans to close down charter schools run by the indicted Newpoint Education Partners, the Florida Times-Union reports.

GENDER ISSUES: Gov. Rick Scott gets pressure to join a multi-state lawsuit challenging the Obama administration's position on transgender students and school restrooms, the Palm Beach Post reports.

BAD ACTS: A Highlands teacher is arrested on charges of sexual misconduct with a student, Highlands Today reports. …

Full Story

Florida third graders without reading test scores have few options for promotion, state says

Parents in several Florida counties are getting angry as they receive word that their children face another year of third grade, despite their classroom performance.

It's all because the children opted out of the Florida Standards Assessments, and don't want to take a different exam to prove they deserve to move on -- regardless of what state statute requires.

Parents from Manatee and Seminole counties told stories of their high achieving children being told they needed to take an alternate test or provide a portfolio proving their reading mastery to avoid retention. They contend they're being threatened, and suggest their children's report cards, progress reports and other materials should suffice.

That's what is happening in some other districts, they say.

But unlike a year ago, when districts had more flexibility to make promotion decisions because the state had not issued FSA scores, the options are more limited this spring. Department of Education officials told district leaders during a Wednesday conference call that the law is clear: Testing is required, and a score of Level 1 means retention unless a student gains a good cause promotion. It reads, in relevant part: …

Full Story

Pasco teacher's discrimination case appears headed to court

A Pasco County teacher is suing the school district in federal court over accusations that she was demoted for wanting to become a mother.

Buffey Simon Leonard first made these allegations in 2012, as she was removed from her assistant principal post at Hudson Middle School. She said her then-principal and assistant superintendent, both of whom no longer hold those posts, took her out of the administration after she asked questions about how her schedule might work if she were to become a parent.

Simon Leonard later was removed from the district's administrative pool, and not accepted when she reapplied.

She filed a complaint with the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, which did not find in her favor. She next turned to federal court to seek relief.

District officials have attempted to settle this case, discussing it in executive session to review details as recently as March. But Dennis Alfonso, the School Board's attorney, said the sides could not reach agreement.

Lawyers have been taking depositions this week leading up to the anticipated trial. Read the complaint for more details. …

Full Story

Florida education news: Vouchers, third-grade retention, maternity leave and more

VOUCHERS: A state audit finds problems in the way student eligibility is determined for Florida personal learning scholarships.

TESTING: Manatee third graders who refuse state testing won't be promoted to fourth grade, the Bradenton Herald reports.

GRADUATION RATES: Orange County leaders cheer the district's rising graduation rate at traditional high schools, a number that differs from state reports, the Orlando Sentinel reports.

VIOLENCE: A student is hospitalized after a stabbing inside a Palm Beach high school restroom, WPEC reports.

CIVIL RIGHTS: The Palm Beach school district faces a federal complaint over accusations it demoted an assistant principal for taking maternity leave, the Palm Beach Post reports. • The arrest of a Brevard School Board candidate for his outburst at a board meeting raises free speech debate, Florida Today reports.

GENDER ISSUES: Lake and Sumter schools will not change their procedures or rules relating to transgender students and bathrooms, the Daily Commercial reports. Florida does not join 11 states challenging the Obama administration's latest directive on the issue, the Orlando Sentinel reports. More from Politico Florida. …

Full Story

Union endorses three in Hillsborough School Board races

Cindy Stuart, vice chairwoman of the Hillsborough County School Board, is running for re-election in north Hillsborough's District 3.

Cindy Stuart, vice chairwoman of the Hillsborough County School Board, is running for re-election in north Hillsborough's District 3.

The Hillsborough Classroom Teachers Association is backing an incumbent, a political leader and a retired administrator in this year's Hillsborough County School Board races.

The union, representing nearly 20,000 district employees including teachers, teaching assistants and school counselors, is endorsing Cindy Stuart, who is running for re-election in north Hillsborough's District 3.

In District 1, which covers west Hillsborough and Town 'N Country, the union is backing Bill Person, a retired administrator who hopes to unseat incumbent Susan Valdes.

In the at-large District 7 race, Alan Clendenin has the union's nod. Clendenin, a former air traffic controller, is a leader in the state Democratic party.

In Central Tampa's District 5, where incumbent Doretha Edgecomb has chosen not to compete, there is no endorsement yet. "We are going to hold additional meetings to get to know District 5 candidates better," said Stephanie Baxter-Jenkins, the union's executive director. …

Full Story

FEA has no plan to abandon challenge of tax credit scholarships, union president says

A circuit judge's ruling against claims that Florida failed to provide a uniform and high quality public school education had Senate president Andy Gardiner celebrating the affirmation of lawmakers' role, and more.

In a prepared statement, Gardiner proclaimed that the judgment supported "the constitutionality of school choice options that allow tens of thousands of low-income children to attend private schools and provide parents of children with unique abilities the option to choose the educational format best suited to their child's needs."

He added that the judge "specifically rejected claims made by the Plaintiffs by stating that the Florida Tax Credit Scholarship does not divert funds or have any detrimental impact on public schools."

In his own words, the judge wrote:

"The Court has already held that Plaintiffs lack standing to challenge the FTC Program, and the Court further concludes that the weight of the evidence does not support their speculative allegations that the FTC Program diverts state funding or has any material, detrimental effect on Florida's system of public schools. …

Full Story